On an ideological level, prosecutions may be difficult to achieve. The politics of truth and reconciliation in south africa by richard a. The report of the truth and reconciliation commission was presented to. This article empirically assesses the effectiveness of the truth and. Truth and reconciliation commission, south africa trc, courtlike body established by the new south african government in 1995 to help heal the country and bring about a reconciliation of its people by uncovering the truth about human rights violations that had occurred during the period of. It marked a turning point in the history of south africa as a nation and its importance cannot be overlooked or negated. In south africa, in contrast to other nations emerging from a tyrannical past e.
South africas imperfect progress, 20 years after the. Reconciliation is a process of bringing people with differences together and helping them. The south african judiciary has not been overturned with the transition to democracy, and it continues to hold sway with the white elite dyzenhaus 1998. Consolidating the rule of law for the new villains. Relations congressional research service summary south africa is a multiracial, majority black southern african country of nearly 52 million.
It is in this respect that the achievements of the truth and reconciliation commission stand out. Souths africas violent and complex history is chronicled in the fivevolume truth and reconciliation commission of south africa report, a chilling record of the hearings that exposed atrocities perpetrated by the south african apartheid government and opposing parties over. Some lessons for societies in transition by graeme simpson this paper was written prior to the publication of. However, as wilson shows, the trcs restorative justice approach to healing the nation did not always serve the needs of communities at a local level. Cambridge core human rights the politics of truth and reconciliation in south africa by richard a. I have entitled this paper common past, divided truth. However, the trcs restorative justice approach did not always serve the needs of communities at a local level. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple faq for additional information. South africas truth and reconciliation commission perceptions of xhosa, afrikaner, and english south africans jay a.
The truth and reconciliation commission trc was a courtlike restorative justice body assembled in south africa after the end of apartheid. A select bibliography on the south african truth and reconciliation commission debate, journal of. When i arrived in cape town at the end of january, i had very little understanding of what the south african truth and. In an attempt to reach all sectors of the community, especially those. The truth and reconciliation commission trc was created in south africa in 1995, after the end of apartheid. Evaluating the truth and reconciliation commission of. South africas truth and reconciliation commission has admitted it failed to give a full and balanced account of abuses under apartheid. South african public for the systemic political and socioeconomic violations of apartheid. This would be linked to the trcs work of drawing a bright line. Legitimizing the postapartheid state, richard wilson, cambridge university press, 2001. Description of the book the politics of truth and reconciliation in south africa. The south african governments principal armed opponent, umkhonto wesizwe mk also recognised, after the arrest of many of its personnel and the destruction of its internal organisation in the early 1960s, that its war had of necessity to be waged from outside south africa. Witnesses who were identified as victims of gross human rights violations were invited to give statements about their experiences, and.
First, the trc is an outcome of political negotiation and strategy of accommodation between opposing political forces that characterized the moment of transition. The following members were appointed to the human rights violations committee. Consideration was given to regional needs as well as the wish to ensure the broadest possible representation in terms of skills, culture, language, faith and gender. It held its first universal suffrage elections in 1994, after a transition from white minority rule under. The gold standard for how a divided society with a violent past might work through that past and move forward was set 20 years ago by south africas truth and reconciliation commission. I have just modified 2 external links on truth and reconciliation commission south africa. The truth and reconciliation commission the commission asked all south africans who had suffered in the political conflicts of the past to come to the commission and make a statement. The south african truth and reconciliation commissions contribution to dealing with the past, reconciling and building the nation article pdf available july 2006 with 3,6 reads. The promotion of national unity and reconciliation. Truth and reconciliation commission kids britannica.
The origins of truth and reconciliation commissions. Center for the study of violence and reconciliation. Truth to reconciliation lessons from south africa james l. Truth and reconciliation commission of south africa report.
When nelson mandela appointed him to chair the truth and reconciliation commission in south africa, he became the public face of an extraordinary process. The commission was set up to investigate atrocities committed both by the apartheid government and by antiapartheid forces between 1960 and 1994, and to foster reconciliation among south africans. Witnesses who were identified as victims of gross human rights violations were invited to give statements about their experiences, and some were selected for public hearings. Our country is soaked in the blood of her children of all races and of all political persuasions. The truth and reconciliation commission in south african public. Restorative justice and the south african truth and. This case study explores the religious underpinnings of south africas truth and reconciliation commission, a governmental body established to facilitate the peaceful transition from the apartheid government to a truly democratic society by exposing human rights violations and administering both justice and forgiveness. South africa truth and reconciliation commission ap archive.
Inside south africas truth and reconciliation commission. Academic articles truth and reconciliation commission. Pdf this article enquires into the narration of reconciliation in south africa and its political implications. One of the scariest things about having my time in south africa quickly coming to an end is that there is so much i still need to learn about this place. The article also examines whether the trc was viewed as having had a positive effect on south africas society, economy, politics, and image in the world. Deliberating truth and reconciliation in south africa, katherine elizabeth mack brings these scholarly and creative conversations together to contribute a fresh, perceptive, and clear rhetorical perspective on the fiercely contested question of the trcs success. On the one hand, it is an examination of the culture and customs of the xhosa, one of the principle ethnic groups in the republic of south africa. The south african truth and reconciliation commission trc was set up to deal with the human rights violations of apartheid.
The effectiveness of south africas truth and reconciliation. Graybill is also disappointed about the sacrifices of the whites and their positive involvement in the building of a new south africa. Gibson department of political science washington university in st. The truth and reconciliation commission of south africa would serve this purpose. The contributions of truth to reconciliation citeseerx. Evaluating the truth and reconciliation commission elizabeth stanley abstract following a negotiated transition to democracy in south africa, the truth and reconciliation commission trc was established to deal with crimes of the past regime. Discourse around the trc focused on the importance of bearing witness to the past, and on the healing powers of forgiveness. Truth and reconciliation commission south africa wikipedia. Every truth commission before this one has made recommendations that were not implemented in a timely fashion or, in most cases, not implemented at all. On the other hand, it is an examination of the truth and.
A survey of literature on the south african truth and reconciliation commission, journal of language and politics, 51, 2006, pp. South africas truth and reconciliation commission south africas trc archive list of participants the goetheinstitut, in association with the nelson mandela foundation and the rosa luxemburg foundation, initiated a workshop in johannesburg on 4 april 2009 for stakeholders in the kenyan truth, justice and reconciliation commission tjrc. A brief evaluation of south africas truth and reconciliation commission. Dr moon situates the appearance of the trc in 1995 at the juncture of then emerging national and. Based on extended anthropological fieldwork, this book illustrates the impact of the trc in. Summary of the politics of truth and reconciliation in south africa.
Only by revisiting the trauma of the past can people look to a better future but with the truth comes pain and a reminder that reconciliation may still be a distant goal in the new south africa. Offers a background to the trc process then reckons with gibsons study in terms of his procedures, the context, the issue of race, the truth claims of the trc, a digression on amnesty, and finally the link between truth and reconciliation. Louis and centre for comparative and international politics stellenbosch university, south africa the south african truth and reconciliation commission trc is undoubtedly the most widely. Twenty years of south african democracy freedom house. Legislation to establish a truth and reconciliation commission trc was passed soon after election of south africas first democratic government. The highlyacclaimed case of south africa represents the first case in which a truth and reconciliation commission trc, rather. For as much material as the author covers, she also leaves out a lot of unanswered questions. The south african truth and reconciliation commission trc was set up to deal with the human rights violations of apartheid during the years 19601994. South africa truth and reconciliation commission youtube. South africas truth and reconciliation commission trc has had an enormous influence on how people think about truth commissions and transitional justice.
Children and the south african truth and reconciliation. Wilson summary written by eric brahm, conflict research consortium citation. The south african truth and reconciliation commission trc is. Justice in perspective truth and justice commission, africa south africa. The contested truth of the south african truth and reconciliation. Instead, reconciliation was sought through the perpetrators and survivors own truthtelling of the incidents of gross human rights violations, which, in effect, made possible the public and official moral condemnation of such crimes. The truth and reconciliation commission is a major milestone trc in south african history as it was part of the vehicle of transition between the past and the future of the new south africa. Summary of the politics of truth and reconciliation in. The truth and reconciliation commission in south africa. The south african truth and reconciliation com mission trc was set up to deal with the human rights violations of apartheid during the years. Cloud state university this article empirically assesses the effectiveness of the truth and reconciliation commission trc of south africa as perceived by three ethnic. Narrating political reconciliation advances a distinctive political discourse of south africas truth and reconciliation commission trc, and provides the first book length theoretical interpretation of the social and political construction of truth and reconciliation in south africa. This is what has inspired me to look deeper into the issue of rj and the south african truth and reconciliation process in this article.
Twenty years of south african democracy executive summary after 20 years of democracy, south africans celebrate that human rights have been realized and that society is transforming. Often, the political pressure to implement the recommendations of a truth commission fades as soon as the commission finishes its work and issues its report. The main task of the trc was to promote national unity and reconciliation in south africa. Truth and reconciliation commission, south africa south. One of the central issues in the talks over ending apart heid in south africa was amnesty. The south african truth and reconciliation commission and public opinion.
Would it go the way of blanket amnesty in the name of political expediency and ignore the fate of its victims. History, historians and the south african truth and. However, there was also a concern that individuals with trc relevant experience would simply be retraumatized by. Human rights and political transition in south africa. The politics of truth and reconciliation in south africa. It is simply impossible to write a history of south africa without erring on one side or another of the argument. Accountability and national reconciliation in south africa csvr. Of the numerous commissions that have been established over the last twenty years, the majority have been simply classified as truth commissions. While there is strong disappointment with the government and its leaders. Truth and reconciliation in south africa 79 and the governments commitment to social justice.
1553 739 512 270 1559 1064 138 819 889 771 887 419 992 886 1475 319 1299 1336 739 1603 1474 1099 562 357 537 1247 442 75 765 1054 332 928 64 306 385 145